Butter and Whisk

Build your dream box. Our Build A Box option allows you to create your perfect box. Perfect for family get togethers, meetings, or sampling multiple flavors at one time.

In this box you will combine up to 12 cookies in any flavor combination you choose.

Try out Butter and Whisk

Give the gift of cookies! 🍪

Treat someone special to a little something sweet with a Butter & Whisk Cookie Co. gift card. Perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank-yous, teacher gifts, or just because!

Gift cards can be used toward any of our homemade cookies, seasonal flavors, signature collection, cookie boxes, and more. Whether they’re a classic chocolate chip kind of person or always ready to try the newest seasonal flavor, there’s something for every cookie lover.

Homemade classics. Modern flair. Always baked with love. 🤎

Gift cards are available in multiple denominations and make the perfect gift for the cookie lover in your life!

The Whisk Pick

A dozen cookies featuring the baker’s favorite seasonal flavors, handpicked from what’s fresh and delicious at Butter & Whisk.

The lineup changes with the seasons, so there’s always something new to try. Consider this your invitation to let the Whisk do the choosing. 😉

The best way to experience Butter and Whisk. Our Signature Box includes a handpicked assortment of our six signature cookies, featuring two of each flavor for the perfect mix of timeless favorites and customer-loved classics. Whether you're sharing with family, bringing dessert to the office, or treating yourself, this dozen is the perfect introduction to everything Butter and Whisk has to offer.

Includes:

• 🍪 Signature Chocolate Chip (2)
• 🥜 Classic Peanut Butter (2)
• 🌳 Walnut Grove (2)
• 🍫 Midnight Melt (2)
• 🌾 Ranch House Oatmeal (2)
• 🎈 Balloon Drop (2)

Freshly baked from scratch and beautifully boxed, ready to share... or keep all to yourself.